Posted On: February 15, 2007 by Finch McCranie, LLP

Tractor-Trailer Insurance in Georgia is Inadequate

Georgia law with respect to the financial responsibility for common carriers needs to be changed and it needs to be changed quickly. Simply stated, the minimum limits of insurance protection that is now available to the public is grossly inadequate and far less than federal limits. It is high time that Georgia enacts legislation which is at least as effective as federal law in protecting innocent members of the motoring public when it comes to the type of carnage that can be inflicted by a negligent trucking company.

In order to operate as a motor carrier in Georgia, a company must first obtain a certificate of public convenience pursuant to O.C.G.A. § 46-7-3. Under rules adopted by the Georgia Public Service Commission, in order to obtain a certificate of public convenience, a carrier must provide the State with a surety bond of only $100,000.00 for bodily injury or death of one person and $300,000.00 for bodily injury or death of all persons involved in an accident. This standard was issued by the Georgia Public Service Commission (PSC) under its Rule 7-2.1. Alternatively, the Georgia PSC stated that a motor carrier could present the PSC with proof of insurance in the same amount and that the proof could be the actual policy itself or a certificate of coverage from the insurance company.

The Certificate of Insurance in Georgia is known as a Form E (Uniform Motor Carrier Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability Certificate of Insurance). The purpose of this insurance is to protect the innocent members of motoring public who may be damaged by the carrier’s operations. Unfortunately, in a case involving serious injury or death, $100,000.00 is clearly inadequate to address such a situation. Indeed, in any serious case where the injured victim remains in the hospital sometimes for days or weeks, the $100,000.00 minimum limits of insurance coverage is hardly sufficient to even compensate the victim for his or her medical expenses much less lost wages, pain and suffering and/or permanent disability caused by the injury. Unfortunately, the Georgia Legislature which is dominated by a business lobby mentality, does not seem very interested in calling for an amendment to this Rule. “Let them eat cake” seems to be the attitude which we have a hard time understanding. After all, we are talking about innocent victims.

Under federal law, the minimum limits of insurance coverage for the protection of the public is $750,000.00. Most responsible trucking companies carry much more by way of liability insurance coverage then the minimum limits because their assets are at risk in a serous case. Many responsible trucking companies carry 5 - 10 million dollars in coverage, and sometimes more. In a serious case where amputations are involved, paralysis, death or other truly severe injuries, such coverage is necessary to compensate the innocent third party victim who may be involved in an accident with a large truck. If a driver loses control, is speeding, crosses the centerline or otherwise strikes the innocent third party who has done absolutely nothing wrong, one can be assured that with the size of some of these rigs, the innocent third party will be severely damaged. If the person survives the injury, that person may undergo months, if not years, of pain and suffering not to mention a loss of their lifestyle, their job and the emotional stress attendant to such a situation which literally always affects the entire family. In such circumstances, it is ludicrous for the State of Georgia to have coverage limits of $100,000.00 to cover a serious injury or death. Indeed, $100,000.00 is the most any single person can collect from such an accident in Georgia and even if ten people were killed in a van, let’s say, coming back from a church, the most the family members could receive would be a total of $300,000.00 to be divided ten ways from a minimum limits carrier. In short, if a trucking company is irresponsible enough to carry minimum limits, they are still within the law and can operate legally in Georgia. If they have no assets at risk because they are a “fly by night carrier,” they are not likely to carry more coverage.

It is not clear why such wholly inadequate limits of insurance were ever set to begin with by the Georgia PSC particularly in view of the fact that the federal government has always had far greater limits. There is no reason why someone in Georgia should receive only $100,000.00 whereas if they are injured by an interstate carrier with the exact same injury, the exact same facts and exact same damages that nonetheless they would be able to receive as much as $750,000.00. There is also no reason why someone in Alabama should get $750,000.00 (because of an interstate truck accident) but the same person just across the state line in Georgia would be limited to $100,000.00 if an intrastate trucking company caused the damage.

We recently tried to convince a federal judge that Georgia law should not protect intrastate truck companies that carry greater limits of federal coverage. Our efforts were rejected, however, when a federal judge recently ruled that because state law provides such minimum limits that when an intrastate carrier is involved the injured plaintiff has no redress but to obtain the minimum limits afforded by Georgia law even if higher federal limits are possessed by the carrier. We urge the Georgia Legislature and all responsible officials in this area to implement changes immediately so that the public is provided with a greater measure of protection than currently exists. $100,000.00 is not sufficient and while $750,000.00 is much better, in the case of serious injury (amputation or paralysis) the greater amount is arguably inadequate for the innocent victim of a trucking company’s negligence.